The Most Exclusive Neighborhoods in Sarasota, FL

The Most Exclusive Neighborhoods in Sarasota, FL

Sarasota, FL, is renowned for its beautiful beaches, vibrant arts scene, and luxurious living options. For those seeking the pinnacle of elegance and exclusivity, Sarasota offers several neighborhoods that epitomize luxury living. This guide explores the most exclusive neighborhoods in Sarasota, FL, highlighting what makes each unique. Explore the best of what Sarasota offers.

Bird Key

Bird Key is a prestigious island community. Known for its stunning waterfront properties and deep-water canals, Bird Key offers unparalleled views of Sarasota Bay and easy access to the Gulf of Mexico. This exclusive enclave features a mix of luxurious single-family homes, many of which come with private docks, making it a haven for boating enthusiasts.

Residents of Bird Key enjoy a tranquil, private lifestyle with close proximity to the cultural and dining attractions of downtown Sarasota. The Bird Key Yacht Club is a central hub for social activities, offering dining, boating, and fitness facilities.

Siesta Key

Siesta Key is world-famous for its powdery white sand beaches and crystal-clear waters. This barrier island boasts some of the most luxurious real estate near Sarasota, FL, with a range of properties from sprawling beachfront estates to upscale condos. The laid-back island lifestyle, combined with top-tier amenities, makes Siesta Key a prime location for luxury living.

In addition to its stunning beaches, Siesta Key offers a vibrant village area with boutique shopping, fine dining, and lively nightlife. The island is also home to several exclusive gated communities, such as The Sanderling Club, which offers private beach access and luxurious amenities for its residents.

Lido Key

Lido Key, located just west of downtown Sarasota, is another exclusive neighborhood known for its luxurious homes and upscale condos. This island offers a resort-style living experience with its pristine beaches, high-end resorts, and the renowned St. Armands Circle, which features world-class shopping and dining options.

Lido Shores, a prominent community on Lido Key, is famous for its mid-century modern architecture and waterfront properties. Residents enjoy a blend of modern luxury and historical charm, with easy access to recreational activities like kayaking, paddleboarding, and sailing​.

The Oaks Club

The Oaks Club, located just south of downtown Sarasota, is an exclusive gated community known for its elegant homes and world-class amenities. This country club community features two championship golf courses, a state-of-the-art tennis facility, and a luxurious clubhouse offering fine dining and social events.

Homes in The Oaks Club range from grand estates to upscale villas, all set within beautifully landscaped grounds. The community’s dedication to preserving its natural beauty and providing top-tier amenities makes it a premier choice for luxury living in Sarasota, FL​.

Downtown Sarasota

For those who prefer an urban lifestyle, downtown Sarasota offers a blend of luxury condos and sophisticated city living. The downtown area is bustling with cultural attractions, including the Sarasota Opera House, The Ringling Museum of Art, and the Van Wezel Performing Arts Hall.

High-rise condos in downtown Sarasota provide stunning views of Sarasota Bay and the city skyline. Residents enjoy walkable access to fine dining, boutique shopping, and vibrant nightlife. Some of the most sought-after condo buildings include The Ritz-Carlton Residences, Vue Sarasota Bay, and The Jewel​.

Harbor Acres

Harbor Acres is one of Sarasota’s most prestigious waterfront communities, located just south of downtown. This exclusive neighborhood is known for its luxurious estates, many of which feature private docks and panoramic views of Sarasota Bay. The lush, tree-lined streets and large lots provide a sense of privacy and tranquility.

Homes in Harbor Acres are highly coveted for their architectural beauty and prime waterfront location. The community’s close proximity to downtown Sarasota and the Sarasota Memorial Hospital adds to its desirability, making it a top choice for luxury living​.

West of the Trail

The area known as “West of the Trail” refers to neighborhoods located west of U.S. Route 41, also known as the Tamiami Trail. This area is celebrated for its historical charm, beautiful homes, and proximity to Sarasota Bay. Neighborhoods like Cherokee Park and McClellan Park feature a mix of historic homes and modern estates, offering a unique blend of old-world elegance and contemporary luxury.

Residents of West of the Trail enjoy easy access to downtown Sarasota, top-rated schools, and the Southside Village area, which offers a variety of dining and shopping options. This neighborhood is ideal for those seeking a prestigious address with a rich history.

Partner with the Kim Ogilvie Group

Ready to explore the most exclusive neighborhoods in Sarasota, FL, and find your dream luxury home? Reach out to the Kim Ogilvie Group today. With extensive experience in Sarasota, FL, the Kim Ogilvie Group provides unparalleled expertise and personalized service to help you navigate the luxury real estate market. Contact the Kim Ogilvie Group today.

*Header image courtesy of the Kim Ogilvie Group

Work With Kim

Dedicated and passionate about her craft, she has reached a position in the industry few ever attain. Kim’s list of accolades is extensive and includes: 2021 Michael Saunders & Company Top Performing Agent; multiple years of leading the top producing team with Michael Saunders & Company; Sarasota Association of Realtors® Sales Leader of $1M+ in single-family homes over a cumulative 15-year period; and involvement in three of the five largest sales in Sarasota history.

Follow Kim on Instagram