Casey Key

Casey Key, Florida, epitomizes beachfront tranquility. This barrier island, accessible by a scenic swing bridge, offers a private escape nestled amidst the turquoise waters of the Gulf of Mexico. Immaculate estates and sprawling residences with private docks define the real estate landscape, promising unparalleled water access and stunning coastal views. Despite its seclusion, Casey Key boasts a vibrant community spirit, with residents enjoying pristine beaches, world-class fishing, and opportunities for watersports. The nearby mainland towns of Sarasota and Venice provide access to cultural attractions, fine dining, and shopping, while Casey Key itself maintains a peaceful and relaxed atmosphere. Ideal for those seeking a luxurious island retreat with a strong sense of community, Casey Key offers an unparalleled Florida living experience.
 
 

Frequently Asked Questions about Casey Key Real Estate:

1. What is the current state of the Casey Key housing market?

Casey Key's real estate market has historically been characterized by exclusivity and high-value properties. While 2024 has seen some moderation in price appreciation compared to the previous year, the market remains competitive. Inventory levels are low, with a high demand for waterfront properties and luxury estates. This trend suggests a seller's market, where qualified buyers may need to be prepared to act quickly to secure their dream island property.

2. What types of properties are available in Casey Key?

Casey Key caters to a high-end market, with single-family homes dominating the landscape. These range from luxurious waterfront estates with private docks and expansive living areas to meticulously designed beach bungalows offering a more intimate feel. Vacant lots are rarely available due to the limited developable space on the island. Condominiums or multi-family units are virtually nonexistent, further solidifying the focus on private residences.

3. What are the advantages of living in Casey Key?

Beyond the undeniable allure of beachfront living and unparalleled water access, Casey Key offers a unique island lifestyle. Residents enjoy a strong sense of community, with a focus on outdoor activities and a relaxed pace of life. The proximity to the mainland provides access to the cultural offerings and amenities of Sarasota and Venice, while Casey Key itself maintains a peaceful and secluded atmosphere. Additionally, with limited commercial development, the island prioritizes natural beauty and tranquility.

4. What are some things to consider before buying in Casey Key?

The cost of living in Casey Key is one of the highest in Florida. Real estate prices reflect this exclusivity, making it a significant investment. Due to the island's seclusion, car ownership is essential for navigating the island and accessing amenities on the mainland. Additionally, with a focus on single-family homes, Casey Key might not be ideal for those seeking a low-maintenance lifestyle or a more social, condo-style environment.

5. Is Casey Key a good place to retire?

Casey Key offers a tranquil and picturesque environment ideal for retirees seeking a luxurious island retreat. The relaxed pace of life, stunning natural beauty, and close proximity to cultural attractions on the mainland make it an attractive option. However, the high cost of living, limited availability of single-story homes, and potential isolation for those without a car might be considerations for retirees on a budget or seeking a more social and walkable community.

 

Search All Homes

Overview for Casey Key, FL

583 people live in Casey Key, where the median age is 62 and the average individual income is $155,959. Data provided by the U.S. Census Bureau.

583

Total Population

62 years

Median Age

High

Population Density Population Density This is the number of people per square mile in a neighborhood.

$155,959

Average individual Income

Demographics and Employment Data for Casey Key, FL

Casey Key has 271 households, with an average household size of 2. Data provided by the U.S. Census Bureau. Here’s what the people living in Casey Key do for work — and how long it takes them to get there. Data provided by the U.S. Census Bureau.

583

Total Population

High

Population Density Population Density This is the number of people per square mile in a neighborhood.

62

Median Age

61.23 / 38.59%

Men vs Women

Population by Age Group

0-9:

0-9 Years

10-17:

10-17 Years

18-24:

18-24 Years

25-64:

25-64 Years

65-74:

65-74 Years

75+:

75+ Years

Education Level

  • Less Than 9th Grade
  • High School Degree
  • Associate Degree
  • Bachelor Degree
  • Graduate Degree
271

Total Households

2

Average Household Size

$155,959

Average individual Income

Households with Children

With Children:

Without Children:

Marital Status

Married
Single
Divorced
Separated

Blue vs White Collar Workers

Blue Collar:

White Collar:

Commute Time

0 to 14 Minutes
15 to 29 Minutes
30 to 59 Minutes
60+ Minutes

The Sarasota, FL Real Estate Market

Here are some key statistics as of October 2024

$486,000

Median Sale Price

$377

Median Sale Price per Square Foot

76

Days on Market

Work With Kim

Dedicated and passionate about her craft, she has reached a position in the industry few ever attain. Kim’s list of accolades is extensive and includes: 2021 Michael Saunders & Company Top Performing Agent; multiple years of leading the top producing team with Michael Saunders & Company; Sarasota Association of Realtors® Sales Leader of $1M+ in single-family homes over a cumulative 15-year period; and involvement in three of the five largest sales in Sarasota history.

Follow Kim on Instagram