Casey Key
Ultimate Privacy, Pristine Gulf Beaches, and Irreplaceable Island Solitude.
Sarasota Barrier Island Sanctuary
Casey Key is Sarasota County's most exclusive barrier island in zip code 34275 between Nokomis and Osprey, with fewer than 500 year-round residents. Is Casey Key a private place to live? Yes. It features direct Gulf-front mansions, private docks, an uncrowded beach, zero commercial development, and a single main road with no through traffic.
Whether you seek a beachfront compound or a bayfront home with a private boat dock, Kim Ogilvie Group provides private access to off-market inventory across the island.
Uncrowded Gulf-front living, private Intracoastal boating, and complete seclusion located 20 minutes south of Downtown Sarasota.
Island Highlights
Casey Key offers genuine solitude, pristine natural beaches, and deep-water boating access. High-profile individuals choose the island for its strict residential zoning, absence of commercial foot traffic, and complete privacy.
Strictly limited to single-family residential properties with no hotels, retail shops, or chain restaurants, preserving an undisturbed coastal sanctuary.
Features pristine Gulf frontage on the west and private boat docks on the east, enabling immediate Gulf access through nearby Venice Inlet.
Conveniently located near Pine View School in Osprey alongside the fine arts, dining, and theater venues of Sarasota and Venice.
With no vacant development land, property values benefit from an enduring scarcity premium where new builds occur solely via teardown-and-rebuild projects.
Coastal Lifestyle
Living on Casey Key places residents near North Jetty Park fishing, Oscar Scherer State Park kayaking, and coastal dining at Casey Key Fish House. Drive times average 10 to 15 minutes to Venice and 20 minutes to Downtown Sarasota.
Explore island living during seasonal milestones like turtle nesting season on Casey Key.
North Jetty Park: 1000 S Casey Key Rd, Nokomis, FL | Beachfront park and fishing jetty
Casey Key Fish House: 801 Blackburn Point Rd, Osprey, FL | Waterfront dining with boat dockage
Pristine sandy shoreline featuring sea turtle nesting habitats and minimal pedestrian traffic.
Protected Intracoastal waterways accommodating motor yachts, sailboats, and kayaks.
Popular county park offering shoreline fishing, wildlife watching, and picnic areas.
Nearby nature preserve featuring hiking trails, kayaking, and winter bald eagle nesting sites.
Market Overview
The Casey Key real estate market is among the most exclusive in Florida. Properties range from $2,500,000 for historic beach bungalows or bay-view parcels to well above $12,000,000 for expansive Gulf-front custom estates.
Because the finest Gulf and bay estates trade through private relationships before reaching public MLS channels, working with a dedicated advisor provides critical access. Learn more about Siesta Key or Downtown Sarasota to compare barrier island lifestyles.
Data Snapshot
A concise summary of geography, privacy parameters, and luxury real estate benchmarks across Casey Key, Florida.
Metric / Indicator | Casey Key Benchmark | Luxury Segment Standard |
|---|---|---|
County Name & Location | Sarasota County (Nokomis and Osprey) | Barrier island between Gulf & Intracoastal |
Zip Code Range | 34275 | Direct Gulf Frontage & Deep-Water Docks |
Median Home Price | $2,500,000 to $12,000,000+ | Custom estates & architect teardowns |
Estimated Population | Fewer than 500 year-round residents | Zero commercial zoning / 34275 enclave |
Source: Sarasota County Property Appraiser and Florida REALTORS Market Research. Audited for accuracy against county MLS records.
Related Reading & Resources
Explore additional barrier island enclaves, waterfront communities, and luxury market guides across Sarasota County.
Led by Kim Ogilvie, with over 40 years of specialized luxury real estate experience in Sarasota and Casey Key, the Kim Ogilvie Group has closed over $1,000,000,000 in local real estate sales through Michael Saunders and Company. Our team delivers unmatched local market guidance for buyers and sellers across the Gulf Coast.
Island Inquiries
Casey Key's exclusivity stems from its geography and demographics: fewer than 500 year-round residents, a single main road with no through traffic, zero commercial development, and a fixed supply of real estate with no new development land available.
Yes. Author Stephen King has been a longtime homeowner on Casey Key. His presence on the island reflects its appeal to high-profile individuals who value privacy and anonymity.
Casey Key homes range from approximately $2,500,000 for bay-view positions or historic beach bungalows to well above $12,000,000 for the finest Gulf-front estate homes.
Casey Key is approximately 15 to 20 miles south of downtown Sarasota, which is about a 20-minute drive via US-41. It is also 10 to 15 minutes north of downtown Venice.
Casey Key's appeal is its absence of commercial activity. Island life focuses on Gulf swimming, beachcombing, boating, fishing from private docks, and visiting nearby North Jetty Park and Oscar Scherer State Park.
Start Your Journey
Contact the Kim Ogilvie Group today for private showing arrangements, off-market property access, or a comprehensive market valuation of your Casey Key property.
728 people live in Casey Key, where the median age is 61 and the average individual income is $104,860. Data provided by the U.S. Census Bureau.
Total Population
Median Age
Population Density
Average individual Income
There's plenty to do around Casey Key, including shopping, dining, nightlife, parks, and more. Data provided by Walk Score and Yelp.
Explore popular things to do in the area, including Chef Rolf's New Florida Kitchen, Foxtail Coffee, and Mobil.
| Name | Category | Distance | Reviews |
Ratings by
Yelp
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dining | 1.04 miles | 147 reviews | 3.1/5 stars | |
| Dining | 1.33 miles | 2 reviews | 5/5 stars | |
| Dining | 1.48 miles | 0 reviews | 0/5 stars | |
| Active | 0.85 miles | 0 reviews | 0/5 stars | |
| Active | 0.99 miles | 6 reviews | 5/5 stars | |
| Active | 1.24 miles | 0 reviews | 0/5 stars | |
| Active | 1.35 miles | 0 reviews | 0/5 stars | |
| Active | 1.36 miles | 0 reviews | 0/5 stars | |
| Active | 1.38 miles | 0 reviews | 0/5 stars | |
| Active | 1.48 miles | 0 reviews | 0/5 stars | |
| Nightlife | 1.04 miles | 12 reviews | 3.7/5 stars | |
| Nightlife | 1.49 miles | 0 reviews | 0/5 stars | |
| Beauty | 0.77 miles | 0 reviews | 0/5 stars | |
| Beauty | 0.78 miles | 3 reviews | 5/5 stars | |
| Beauty | 0.78 miles | 1 review | 5/5 stars | |
| Beauty | 0.78 miles | 0 reviews | 0/5 stars | |
| Beauty | 0.78 miles | 1 review | 5/5 stars | |
| Beauty | 0.81 miles | 0 reviews | 0/5 stars | |
| Beauty | 0.81 miles | 0 reviews | 0/5 stars | |
| Beauty | 0.81 miles | 0 reviews | 0/5 stars | |
| Beauty | 0.94 miles | 0 reviews | 0/5 stars | |
| Beauty | 1.04 miles | 0 reviews | 0/5 stars | |
| Beauty | 1.36 miles | 1 review | 5/5 stars | |
|
|
||||
|
|
||||
|
|
||||
|
|
||||
|
|
||||
|
|
Casey Key has 393 households, with an average household size of 2. Data provided by the U.S. Census Bureau. Here’s what the people living in Casey Key do for work — and how long it takes them to get there. Data provided by the U.S. Census Bureau.
Total Population
Population Density Population Density This is the number of people per square mile in a neighborhood.
Median Age
Men vs Women
Population by Age Group
0-9 Years
10-17 Years
18-24 Years
25-64 Years
65-74 Years
75+ Years
Education Level
Total Households
Average Household Size
Average individual Income
Households with Children
With Children:
Without Children:
Blue vs White Collar Workers
Blue Collar:
White Collar:
With more than four decades of experience in Sarasota’s luxury real estate market, the Kim Ogilvie Group has built a reputation for unmatched expertise, market knowledge, and results. Their proven success and deep understanding of Sarasota’s premier neighborhoods make them the trusted choice for buyers and sellers seeking exceptional representation in today’s competitive market. Connect with the Kim Ogilvie Group to put this experience to work for you.
1605 MAIN STREET SARASOTA, FL 34236
1605 MAIN STREET SARASOTA, FL 34236
